PORTLAND, Maine -- Working on an expedited schedule, the state Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday on whether prostitution clients who are videotaped without their knowledge during sex acts have a right to privacy under state law.

A prosecutor urged the Supreme Judicial Court to reinstate 46 invasion-of-privacy counts against Mark Strong Sr., who's accused of helping a Zumba instructor run a prostitution business in the seaside town of Kennebunk.

Defense lawyer Dan Lilley said lawmakers never intended to protect prostitution clients or other criminals from surveillance. The seven-member panel was asked to rule swiftly because jury selection in Strong's trial has been put on hold in York County.

York County Assistant District Attorney Patrick Gordon argued that the state privacy law that protects innocent people in bathrooms and locker rooms also protects people engaging in sex in a private setting.

Chief Justice Leigh Saufley cut him off, pointing out that there's a big difference in sex between "volunteer social companions" and those paying a prostitute for sex.

Gordon told the justices that sexual relations are "the most private, intimate thing that people can do" and that the state intended to protect the privacy of those acts.

Fitness instructor Alexis Wright set up the video equipment and Strong watched from his computer, making thousands of still images from the live video stream, Gordon told the justices.


Advertisement

Wright will be tried at a later date. Both Strong and Wright have pleaded not guilty.