Consumer Reports: Is it really all that good for you?
When you're grocery shopping, here's a good rule of thumb: Be wary of the healthy-sounding words on food packages.
Many terms and phrases aren't regulated by the Food and Drug Administration or the Department of Agriculture, and some that are can be misinterpreted. Consumer Reports lists five phrases that may not mean what you think they do:
• "Light in sodium." This phrase can easily be confused with "low sodium," a term the FDA defines as containing 140 milligrams of sodium or less per serving. But "light in sodium" means that a product has 50 percent or less of the sodium in the manufacturer's regular version — so it can still be fairly salty. Take Pacific Organic Creamy Tomato Soup. The regular version has 750 milligrams of sodium per 1-cup serving. The light-in-sodium version has 380 milligrams per cup. Have that with a few saltines, and you've consumed about 20 percent of the maximum amount of sodium you should have in a day.
• "Lightly sweetened." The FDA has a definition for this term for canned fruit, but not for other foods. For example, Fiber One Honey Clusters cereal has "lightly sweetened" written on the front of its box, but a single cup has 9 grams of sugars, about 2 teaspoons. Consumer Reports notes that the American Heart Association suggests getting just 6 to 9 teaspoons of added sugars per day. You may also see "touch of" honey or brown sugar on a package. Products with that wording can still be pretty sugary. Kellogg's Origins Ancient Grains Blend cereal, with "touch of honey" on the box, has 9 grams of sugars per 3/4 cup, for example — the same amount as in Kellogg's Special K Chocolatey Delight.
• "Whole grain." As with Cheez-It Whole Grain crackers, whole-grain foods can have refined flour. These crackers also contain whole-wheat flour, but have just 1 gram of fiber per serving (27 crackers), 8 grams of fat and 250 milligrams of sodium. If you want whole grain, look for the words "100 percent whole grain" on the package, and check ingredient lists. A whole-grain flour should be the first ingredient, and the product should have no enriched flours at all.
• "No growth-promoting antibiotics." Antibiotics have been fed to farm animals to make them grow faster and prevent disease. That low-dose chronic use creates ideal conditions for breeding superbugs — bacteria that have evolved to become resistant to antibiotics and that can make people sick. Eliminating the use of growth-promoting antibiotics while continuing to use antibiotics for disease prevention can still result in the development of superbugs. There's no nutritional advantage to buying "no antibiotic" meat, but it supports a healthier food system. Consumer Reports suggests looking for meat and poultry labeled "raised without antibiotics," a USDA-defined term that means antibiotics were not used for any purpose.
• "Biodynamic." Biodynamic farming is similar to organic farming but has additional requirements. Biodynamic farms are mostly self-sufficient; fertilizer and animal feed, for example, are grown there instead of being brought in. It is an ecologically sound, sustainable and healthy food production system, making biodynamic foods a good choice. As is the case with organic farming, though, the benefits don't automatically translate to a more nutritious food product. The regular version of Lundberg short-grain brown rice has 0 grams of sugars and 4 percent iron per serving. The biodynamic version has 1 gram of sugars and 2 percent iron per serving. And packaged foods made with biodynamic ingredients can still contain added sugars and/or sodium.
To learn more, visit ConsumerReports.org.
TALK TO US
If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.