Letter: Gun violence, mental illness are distinct issues


To the editor of THE EAGLE:

One child or teen dies or is injured from guns every 30 minutes. More children and teens die from guns every three days than died in the Newtown massacre. The number of children under five killed by guns in 2010 was higher than the number of law enforcement officers killed in the line of duty that same year. Those startling statistics from the Children’s Defense Fund’s 2013 Protect Children not Guns are the outcomes of a gun culture that is absolute in its support of Second Amendment rights to the exclusion of reasonable debate on reforms.

The intensive, media coverage of mass shootings, often at the hands of a man later labeled as mentally ill, only serves to mask the root cause of gun violence. Mental illness and guns are two distinct public policy issues and must not be conflated. The two issues must be separate if we are to make progress in reducing death and injury by guns and improve the mental health system, creating a network of services and supports that assists all people in need of help.

The task will be neither simple nor easy. After all, blaming a deranged killer for a massacre is much more appealing than examining our conflicted love affair with guns. Our gun culture is born out of the iconic American patriot and his musket, the settlers who conquered the western wilderness with their wits and guns, and an entertainment industry that glorifies violence. In his daily blog Joe Nocera of the New York Times stated, "There are an estimated 300 million guns in America, and that’s not going to change anytime soon. But to read The Gun Report is to be struck anew at the reality that most of the people who die from guns would still be alive if we just had fewer of them." www.nytimes.com/2014/02/04/
opinion/nocera-the-gun-report-1-year-late r.html? ref=3Djoenocera.

Despite years of research and scientific breakthroughs, there is much we don’t understand about the brain and mental illness. However, we do have ample evidence to prove that the vast majority of people who are violent are not mentally ill and that the vast majority of people who are diagnosed with a mental illness are not violent. What we do know is that factors such as prior history of violence (stalking, domestic violence), being young and male, and active substance abuse are more reliable predictors of future violence than mental illness. In fact, studies have shown that people with mental illness are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of violence.

From communities in Western Massachusetts to those across the country, change is needed. Gun rights advocates must stop scapegoating mental illness as the cause of gun violence. We must reduce the prejudice and discrimination directed at persons experiencing mental health problems and assure access to comprehensive and compassionate services.

We urge our elected leaders to heed their constituents. We need new public laws and regulations for preventing gun violence. Failure to do so will continue to mean tragic death and heartache for survivors. And, equally important, we need public policies for building a community-based mental health safety net that is wide and deep. Failure to do so will continue to mean unnecessary emergency room visits, hospitalizations, and homelessness, as well as emotional pain for individuals and families.




This letter was written on behalf of the Western Massachusetts Community Mental Health Area Board by John Hornik and Judith Cameron, the current and immediate past presidents of the board.


If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.

Powered by Creative Circle Media Solutions