NECIR: Online hucksters marketing bogus health apps


When the iTunes Store began offering apps that used cellphone light to cure acne, federal investigators knew that hucksters had found a new spot in cyberspace.

"We realized this could be a medium for mischief," said James Prunty, a Federal Trade Commission attorney who helped prosecute the government's only cases against health app developers last year, shutting down two acne apps.

Since then, the Food and Drug Administration has been mired in a debate over how to oversee these new high-tech products and government officials have not pursued any other app developers for making medically dubious claims. Now, both the iTunes store and Google Play store for Android users are riddled with health apps that experts say do not work and in some case could even endanger people.

These apps offer quick fixes for everything from flabby abs to alcoholism, and they promise relief from pain, stress, stuttering, and even ringing in the ears. Many of these apps do not follow established medical guidelines, and few have been tested through the sort of clinical research that is standard for less new-fangled treatments sold by other means, a probe by The New England Center for In vestigative Reporting (NECIR) has found.

While some are free, thousands must be purchased, ranging from 69 cents to $999. Nearly 247 million mobile phone users are expected to download health apps in 2012, according to Research2 Guidance, a global market research firm.

In an examination of 1,500 health apps that cost money and have been available since June 2011, the center found that more than one out of five claims to treat or cure medical problems -- exactly the sorts of apps that FDA-proposed guidelines suggest need regulation. Of the 331 therapeutic apps, nearly 43 percent relied on cellphone sound for treatments. Another dozen used the light of the cell phone, and two others used phone vibrations. Scientists say none of these methods could possibly work for the conditions in question.

‘Bogus' claims

"Virtually any app that claims it will cure someone of a disease, condition or mental health condition is bogus," says John Grohol, an online health technology expert, pointing out that the vast majority of available apps have not been scientifically tested. "Developers are just preying on people's vulnerabilities."

Satish Misra, a physician and managing editor of the app review website iMedical Apps adds: "They take some therapeutic method that is real -- and in some cases experimental -- and create a grossly simplified version of that therapy using the iPhone. Who knows? Maybe it works." But until testing shows otherwise, "my feeling would be that it doesn't."

To be sure, there are many outstanding health apps, particularly those intended for doctors and hospitals, that are helping to revolutionize medical care, according to physicians and others. Among the most well-regarded apps for consumers: Lose It for weight loss, Azumio to measure heart rates, and iTriage to check symptoms and locate the closest hospitals with shortest emergency room wait times.

But consumers have almost no way of distinguishing great high-tech tools from what Prunty called the "snake oil." Without government oversight or independent testing of apps, people mainly rely on developers' advertisements and anonymous online reviews, many of which are positive but some, such as this one, are not: "Shame on Apple for even allowing this piece of crap on here. It preys on people with health issues."

When contacted, Apple declined to discuss anything about its review process for apps. The company has issued lengthy guidelines for app developers, which say it will reject apps that crash, have bugs or do not perform as advertised.

A Google spokeswoman also declined to discuss its app review process or its rules for developers. Google's content guidelines also ban sexually explicit material, gratuitous violence, or anything that may damage users' devices.

The FDA is drafting regulations that outline what types of health apps will need government approval before they can be marketed in the United States. But the regulations have been bogged down by debates, hearings and legislative back and forth over whether government oversight would stifle innovation.

A few private groups, meanwhile, are working to assess the quality of various apps. Misra's iMedicalApps gets health care professionals to review software applications that mainly interest physicians. Happtique, a subsidiary of the Greater New York Hospital Association, is about to launch the nation's first app certification service which will evaluate apps for safety and effectiveness. It will award some apps the high-tech equivalent of the Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval.

"We truly believe people need a trusted source," said Ben Chodor, Happtique's CEO.

Cardiac stress test by phone

Misra, an internal medicine resident at The Johns Hop kins Hospital, says he's most concerned about apps that claim to test or treat consumers for serious diseases. These apps can sometimes give inaccurate information or can lull people into ignoring symptoms that might need medical attention.

Cardiac Stress Test, for instance, says on Google Play (where it sells for $3.07) that it can determine "if you are ready for sports or if your heart is not in a healthy condition." A person takes his heart rate after performing 30 squats in less than 60 seconds, and enters it into the app's calculator, which then reports whether the user's heart is in shape for exercise.

"It's hard not to imagine how this app could give folks a false sense of security," Misra says, noting that assessing someone's cardiac status is not just a matter of looking at heart rate.

Simon Bertrand, who developed the app for his own use, said it is designed to help healthy people monitor their heart, similar to apps that monitor weight or body mass. "If you are in poor health condition go to see a doctor," he said in an email.

Later, in an interview by phone from France, Bertrand said his app was being offered for sale on Google Play within minutes of submitting it to the company. "It's just a test. It's not an application that claims to cure."

Cellphone light as therapy

Apps that rely on cellphone light, meanwhile, cannot possibly have any therapeutic value, experts say. While light treatments can be used to relieve some medical problems, cell phone light is in the wrong spectrum and far too weak to make any impact at all, said the FTC's Prunty.

"Using the light of the cell phone is automatically suspect," Prunty said, which is why the agency decided last year to file complaints against two developers who claimed cell phone light could cure acne.

Cellphone lights are being marketing to treat other conditions too including seasonal affective disorder (SAD), a type of depression that occurs during the winter because of lack of sunlight. But SAD experts say even the most powerful cell phone lights are far too weak to treat depression.

There's also little proof that apps relying on cell phone sounds can be effective, yet there are many such apps.

The New England Center for Investigative Reporting ( is a nonprofit investigative reporting newsroom at Boston University. Marion Halftermeyer, Sarah Kuranda, John Wayne Ferguson, Maddie Powell, Divya Shankar and Elizabeth Peters contributed to this report.


App uses light for treatment.

App uses sound for treatment.

App costs more than $3.



AG Method

Promises relief for everything from insomnia to toothaches by listening to something that sounds like running water for 20-minutes. It combines this with a flashing notification that reads "HEALING IN PROGRESS."



Ringing Relief Pro

Advertised itself as "an easy and inexpensive way to cure your tinnitus. . . Simply play the low frequency hum that sounds best to you for 90 seconds and your ears should ring no more!" Tinnitus is a persistent ringing in the ears, which the app claimed was due to stuck inner ear hairs.



iSAD Lamp

Says it "will put a smile on your face and help wash away the Winter Blues." It tells consumers to turn the phone light to its highest brightness and use the app for 15 to 45 minutes every day.



Cardiac Stress Test

Determines "if you are ready for sports or if your heart is not in a healthy condition." Users take their heart rates after performing 30 squats in less than 60 seconds, and simply enter them into the app's calculator, which then determines whether the user's heart is in shape for exercise.




Used light therapy to treat acne, citing a study in the British Journal of Dermatology, which suggested that light therapy was almost twice as effective as over-the-the counter blemish treatments. After being sued by the FTC, AcneApp settled the case by paying fines of $14,294, but did not admit wrongdoing.




Claims to be able to accurately predict the gender of an unborn baby using a calculator where users enter the birthdates of future parents and grandparents and other complicated algorithms.



Sex Engine Lady

Describes itself as a "portable x-drive booster" and contains suggestive pictures. Apple claims to reject any pornographic apps.


If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.

Powered by Creative Circle Media Solutions