A one-of-a-kind find for a 'one-of-a-kind' collector
Late Pittsfield resident's coin sells for $204,000 at auction
PITTSFIELD — Donald Lutes Jr. didn't let his numismatic legacy define him.
For seven decades, the lifelong city resident owned a rare 1943 bronze Lincoln cent, highly coveted by the coin-collecting community. Over the years, Lutes turned down several offers to sell the penny made of 95 percent copper and 5 percent zinc, hence bronze.
His health failing, the only-child agreed last summer to sell his prized possession at auction, fetching $204,000 in January — four months after his death on Sept. 3. The late 87-year-old had instructed the proceeds from the sale conducted by Heritage Auctions in Orlando, Fla., be donated to the Berkshire Athenaeum, where he was a dedicated volunteer.
The auction was one of the rare public displays of a coin that the Korean War veteran primarily kept to himself.
"He never made a big deal of the coin," said longtime friend Peter Karpenski, owner of Berkshire Hills Coins and Estate Jewelry in Pittsfield.
Lutes' coin-collecting legacy began as a 16-year-old. The junior at Pittsfield High in March, 1947, discovered the famed bronze penny in the change he received after buying lunch in the school cafeteria. A novice coin-collector at the time, his curiosity was piqued by the shiny cent, remembering 1943 pennies were white-colored "steelies."
The U.S. Mint in 1943 switched to zinc-coated steel cents, saving the copper for use in manufacturing shell casings, telephone wires and other vital products necessary to fight World War II.
"Everybody hated those silver pennies, they looked like dimes," Lutes recalled in a Feb. 1, 1998, article in The Berkshire Eagle Sunday Magazine.
Lutes eventually learned the bronze pennies were minted by mistake and he was the first to discover one of the 17 pennies authenticated as being accidentally struck at the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia, according the Numismatic Guaranty Corp. The NGC, one of two professional coin authenticators in the country, certified Lutes' penny as the real deal last summer.
Lutes explained how, what many collectors call, "The King of Mint Errors," came about: "Some copper blanks from the previous year were stuck in the die and those became the copper cents," he told The Eagle in 1998.
Lutes' place in numismatic history was cemented at auction when the penny garnered 30 bids and sold well above the pre-auction estimate of $170,000 to a Concord, Mass., collector, according to Heritage Auctions.
"This coin, for me, is certainly the 'Holy Grail' of mint errors. Rarely today does a discovery piece come to market, after all these years, still in the possession of the original owner," said David Camire, NGC grading finalizer and a mint error expert, in an article published on the NGC website in August.
But for Lutes, his passion for coin collecting seemed to go beyond his moment of steelie fame. In 1957, he joined the Berkshire Coin Club his dedication earned him the first-ever "Life Membership" by the club in 1974. A year later, he began a 40-plus-year avocation with the Berkshire Genealogical Society, forerunner to the Berkshire Family History Association. He served as BFHA president for 32 years, until 2017.
But that wasn't all. Lutes' tireless efforts to accurately index more than 1,500 items in the Berkshire Athenaeum's Local History and Genealogy Department earned him everlasting high praise. In 2007, the library renamed its annual volunteer award The Donald L. Lutes Jr. Volunteer of the Year Award.
"It was important for Don to be needed. The penny was just a story to him," said Ann-Marie Harris, senior technician/first assistant in the library's local history section.
A Berkshire Coin Club member since 1970, Karpenski noted in his eulogy of Lutes, he was a quiet leader.
"Don had a unique personality." he said. "He rarely spoke first, but when he did speak, it was the voice of a very intelligent individual."
Lutes' grandmother's death in the mid-70s sparked his interest in genealogy. She left him a box of papers and artifacts pertaining to the Lutes family history. As the only child of Donald Sr. and Pauline Lutes, he used those items to trace his lineage back to the state's earliest settlers, the Massachusetts Bay Company, Michael Collins recently wrote in a BFHA newsletter.
Lutes personal ancestral journey prompted him to help others chart their past. He later became BFHA president from 1985 to 2017.
He was so heavily involved in all aspects of the local history group, it now takes several people to handle the duties he assumed.
"We did a lot of head shaking and wondered, `How did he do all this?'" said current BFHA president, Jan Rogge.
Brenda Struthers joined the BFHA in the late '70s after Lutes helped her trace her descendants to a family-owned dairy farm in Leeds, Ontario, Canada.
"He took me under his wing and showed me how to look up my genealogy," she said.
Lutes also wouldn't take "no" for answer when he wryly asked Struthers to volunteer for the BFHA.
"He said I didn't have to do much, just raise your hand and say, `I agree with Don,'" she recalled.
As well known as Lutes was for his famous penny, genealogical expertise and indexing at the athenaeum, his personal life was a mystery to many. He was born March 1, 1931, and graduated from Babson College in 1951 with a degree in business administration. He then went on to serve as an Army cryptographic specialist with the U.S. Military Advisory Group to South Korea from 1952 to 1954. Upon his Army discharge, the war veteran joined his father's home-based Lutes & Son, manufacturing and marketing religious art products, including memorial statuary with internal lighting. The successful business eventually relocated into a factory on Fourth Street, where it flourished until the late 1970s. He rarely talked about being married to Isabel (Walsh) Parker from 1986 until her death in 1995. Lutes had no living immediate relatives when he died and often kept to himself away from his club/library activities.
Lutes was a creature of habit, regularly seen at a Friendly's restaurant in Pittsfield, ordering pancakes and a strawberry sundae.
Harris said the athenaeum staff, BFHA and coin club, were Lutes' family. She hopes more people also realize Lutes was more than that guy with a famous penny.
"I don't think we'll every find another one like him — one of a kind."
Dick Lindsay can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org and 413-496-6233
TALK TO US
If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.