Stop the Pipeline Statewide Summit draws hundreds to Fitchburg to plan course of action
FITCHBURG >> They came from across New England, filling the auditorium at Montachusett Regional Vocational Technical School with a single goal: Stopping Kinder Morgan from building a natural-gas pipeline through their communities.
"It's all about the numbers to the proponents. They don't care about the people. They don't care about your home, your farm, your legacy for your children," said Ken Hartlage, president of the Nasboba Conservation Trust in Pepperell. "The experts weren't expecting us to look at those numbers and challenge the conventional wisdom."
Kinder Morgan Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co. is proposing a northeast expansion, beginning in upstate New York, rolling through the Berkshires and North Central part of the state, and ending in Dracut. Kinder Morgan said it needs the pipeline to meet increasing demand. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) makes the final determination on whether the expansion is needed.
More than 500 people attended the summit, with organizers crediting the large turnout to Kinder Morgan's release of alternate routes that could affect even more communities.
Large-scale maps created by residents, compiled using GIS data, showed homes, water resources and protected open spaces.
Lisa Dack, of Phillipston, said she's concerned that the project will benefit a small number of people at the expense of others, especially people living in the western part of the state. Kinder Morgan doesn't know what residents want, she said.
"The lack of knowledge is evident in their plan," she said.
Dack said the project does not affect her directly, but that it is important she show support.
"I value my land. I don't want all this land to be lost. I wouldn't want this to happen to me, so I'm here to support those who are impacted," she said.
Diane Hewitt, of StopNED, said the number of people in the room shows "clarity about our fundamental values and what we hold so dear."
All 39 communities considering nonbinding resolutions opposing the pipeline passed them, Hewitt said.
"Nothing is impossible," she said.
Linda Copp, of Lowell, said the other alternatives should be looked at before the expansion is approved.
"We don't need a pipeline of this size. There are other projects that are less invasive," she said.
Carol Carbonell, also of Lowell, called this project "dangerous."
"You can't live without water. You can't live without air. But we can live without fracked gas," she said.
State Sen. Jamie Eldridge, D-Acton, praised local work being done.
"I think it's the general public who will keep this going," he said.
Eldridge was part of a panel discussion held with other area legislators and focused on how residents can help their local delegation respond to the proposal.
State Rep. Stephen Kulik, D-Worthington, State Sen. Eileen Donoghue, D-Lowell, and state Rep. Sheila Harrington, R-Groton, were also part of the panel. Beverly Woods, executive director of the Northern Middlesex Council of Governments, moderated.
New York-based attorney Anne Marie Garti discussed her experience with the Constitution Pipeline in New York. She laid out ways residents could provide input to FERC, and explained what recourse land owners have against Kinder Morgan.
Among the most important: Entering concerns into the official record without giving Kinder Morgan suggestions on how to improve its plan.
Residents should not allow any survey personnel on their property, and if they have already signed an agreement allowing them, they should file their deny/rescind survey access letters with Kinder Morgan immediately, Garti said.
"Kinder Morgan cannot complete its environmental review if they can't get on your land," she said.
Landowners should also file a document refusing to sign any easement agreement with Kinder Morgan officials.
Additionally, she said, excessive use of eminent domain is against FERC's policy. If a land owner refuses to sign over their land, Kinder Morgan may attempt various legal channels to take their land.
"You have to stay unified if you're going to win this. The whole thing is about dividing and conquering. Don't expect FERC to choose an alternative route. They tend to do what the company wants," she said. "When they (FERC) changes the route, you have to join forces with each other and work against them."
Judith Eiseman, Abbie Jenks and GeorgAnne Greene, all of Pelham, said they are not affected by the proposed pipeline because it does not pass through Pelham. However, they said it was important to come out and show their support and opposition to the project.
Jenks said she is worried that the Quabbin Reservoir could be affected. The Quabbin is the primary water source for Boston and 65 other communities.
"I am concerned about how it could impact the water quality in the area," she said.
There was also a presentation by attorney Shanna Cleveland of the Conservation Law Foundation.
About the Kinder Morgan pipeline proposal
What is the Kinder Morgan pipeline proposal?
The proposed Northeast Energy Direct Project would upgrade the existing pipeline system in New York, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Connecticut. The project is being developed to meet what Kinder Morgan says is the increased need in the Northeast for transportation capacity of natural gas. The proposed project also will address the need for additional pipeline infrastructure and transportation services.
Where does the project stand right now?
Kinder Morgan filed a letter with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on Sept. 15, 2014, to begin the pre-filing procedures. During pre-filing, project officials will work with FERC staff and other interested parties to refine the proposed route and draft an environmental report. Once complete, a formal certificate application seeking FERC approval of the project. This is expected to be filed in September 2015.
Who decides whether the project will be built?
FERC will determine the final route for the project and the location of any compressor stations or other related facilities. It also will ultimately decide if there is truly a need for this expansion.
Can the pipeline cross private property?
Yes, but landowners must give permission to Kinder Morgan to allow surveyors to come onto their land to do any work, including surveys.
Do homeowners have any recourse?
Kinder Morgan plans to negotiate right-of-way agreements with all landowners. In a circumstance where an agreement cannot be reached, Kinder Morgan will consider its legal options, including the use of eminent domain.
Follow Katina Caraganis on Tout and Twitter @kcaraganis.
TALK TO US
If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.